« Survivor to stir the race relations pot? |
Main
| Conspiracy Theory, John Knox Style »
August 23, 2006
George Allen: Not Ready for Prime Time?
The conservative side of the blogosphere hasn't followed the story much, but Virginia Senator George Allen may have sunk his presidential aspirations earlier this month by using an alleged racial slur while on the campaign trail for re-election. For those not following the story, Allen was campaigning in rural Virginia on August 11th when he spotted a 20-year old volunteer for opponent James Webb's campaign videotaping the proceedings. Allen pointed out the young man, S.R. Sidarth, to the audience and asked them to welcome "this fellow here, over here with the yellow shirt, macaca, or whatever his name is" to "America and the real world of Virginia." Sidarth is of Indian ancestry, but was born and raised in Virginia. The offending clip can be found on YouTube.
Now I'd never heard the term before, but depending on whom you ask, the word Allen used is also a racial slur the French use against dark-skinned persons of North African heritage. Allen's campaign has offered conflicting explanations for what Allen said, saying first that Allen wanted to say "mohawk" because of Sidarth's hairstyle, and later amending that remark to say he was combining mohawk and the Spanish caca, so he was calling Sidarth a, um, craphead. Nevertheless, they have been apologizing profusely since.
Regardless of what he was trying to say, I have to wonder why Allen bothered to point out the young man at all. Following your opponent with a camera hoping for embarrassing footage is rather low on the campaign theatrics scale. In fact, it's standard operating procedure. Allen said he was trying to point out that Jim Webb had never been to that part of the state. But is making an example of a 20-year old volunteer the best way to do that? He shouldn't even have acknowledged Sidarth, or at most, given him a wink and a nod on the way out just to say "Yeah, I know you're here." Did the guy really bother Allen that much? You need a thicker skin than that to run for the White House.
Allen's people have to know that his opponents are trying to peg him as a racist, both here in Virginia and for the 2008 presidential race. The New Republic, for example, had articles in two issues this past May about Allen's fascination with the confederate flag (ptui!). They also obviously knew Sidarth was following them around with a camera, hoping for an embarrassing video. But they still allowed Allen to hand their opponent a racial incident on a silver platter.
Allen is not going to lose the Senate race in Virginia. He's too popular and has too much history with the residents of this state. As they say, however, the internet doesn't forget. And with less than two years to go before the 2008 presidential primary season, the conservative movement might be better served by looking elsewhere.
Posted by David Darlington at August 23, 2006 07:48 PM
I don't know, I'm having a hard time believing that Allen was so unsettled by this kid that he'd let loose with a racist insult knowing full well he's on camera, yet he'd be able to come up with a French slur to throw at him. Did Allen's family immigrate from France within the last few generations or something?
My guess is that "macaca" was just some gibberish that popped into Allen's head as he was pointing at the kid, not knowing his real name. He's still guilty of assuming the kid was not Virginian (or even American) because of his ethnicity, which is pretty bad in and of itself.
Posted by: Eric Seymour at August 23, 2006 11:38 PM | permalink
Did Allen's family immigrate from France within the last few generations or something?
According to various media sources, yes. Allen's mother was raised in Tunisia and his grandparents were French colonists in North Africa.
see forex:
http://mediamatters.org/items/200608170001
Posted by: Nick at August 24, 2006 10:01 AM | permalink
I should clarify that I think he may not have been using a racist epithet deliberately. He may just have been trying to be sarcastic and condescending, and his subconscious dredged up something nasty he learned as a child. Either way, though, sarcastic and condescending is bad politics, even without overt racism.
Posted by: Nick at August 24, 2006 10:05 AM | permalink
I'm not surprised he's doing OK in the senate race. The conflicting explanations coming from Allen are a bit odd, but for a lot of us out here in flyover country, the "macaca" episode looked like a lot of opponents stretching things to the limit trying to find a racial insult in a strange word. I don't know whether the critics are right or not, but the attacks on Allen have an odor similar to the "niggardly" episode in DC (http://www.cnn.com/US/9902/04/dc.word.flap/). I think your point about a guy running for president needing a thicker skin is spot on, and will be what kills Allen's presidential ambitions.
Posted by: J at August 24, 2006 10:07 AM | permalink
Um, you evidently have to be from Tunisia to be familiar with the term. Jeffrey Feldman at FRAMESHOP (WARNING: This findings in this post contain language that many readers may find offensive) did some research on the term and found that, " 'Macaca' or 'macaque' is a nasty racial epithet alright. It is often used by American white supremacists to describe black people. In Belgium, it is a racial slur for 'dirty arab.' "
He then links to numerous examples of its usage on sites such as Vanguard News Network Forum and Stormfront White Pride World Wide.
Forget what us liberals are saying about it, I think Ramesh Ponnuru on the NewsHour last week pretty much declared that any national aspirations George Allen might have had are now over. Judging by the latest polls coming out of Virginia, his Senate career might be, too.
BTW, if you believe one of Feldman's commentors (student from Southeastern Asia) who did his grad studies at Duke, the term is quite common/popular among some whites in that part of the country.
Posted by: JohnS at August 24, 2006 11:41 AM | permalink
That should have been, "you evidently DON'T have to be from Tunisia..."
Sorry.
Posted by: JohnS at August 24, 2006 11:42 AM | permalink
So, not only does Allen come across as rather dull, and not only is he so touchy that he was obviously offended by the presence of that cameraman at his event, and not only is he possibly racist, but he uses a FRENCH word to insult someone. Has he not offended every political sensibility imaginable? Here's hoping that McCain holds his frontrunner status. With primary opponents like Allen, that mightn't be difficult.
Posted by: Chuck at August 25, 2006 02:37 PM | permalink
Possibly racist, indeed. Check this article out in the Nation that examines/explains his connections to the Council of Conservative Citizens, the successor organization to the segregationist White Citizens Council and among the largest white supremacist groups in the US.
Posted by: JohnS at August 30, 2006 01:04 PM | permalink
Post a comment