« The Benign Empire |
Main
| Notre Dame Draws Moral Lines, Criticism »
January 25, 2006
The Passion of Kanye West
Kanye West is no stranger to controversy, so much so that his outlandish antics are expected. But his latest foray into Rolling Stone magazine gives me an excuse to do some exploration. According to the Associated Press Kanye appears on the cover as a tortured Christ-like figure. "The Passion of Kanye West" greets us inside. Among other things we learn that his hit song "Gold Digger" was slighted in the Grammys, and that he has had an addiction to pornography since the age of five.
The famed rapper's most notorious comments though were during a telethon for victims of Hurricane Katrina, when he blurted out that "George Bush doesn't care about black people." Those comments eventually caught up with him when he was loudly booed at a pre-NFL game concert.
Yet Kanye is someone to be taken seriously. Barbara Walters's 2005 10 Most Fascinating People list included him and last fall Time magazine named him "the smartest man in pop music" and "Hip Hop's Class Act". Normally Time magazine's stamp of approval would carry little weight with me, but there is indeed something to be said for Kanye's work.
His most recent Grammy-nominated album Late Registration carries "Gold Digger", a single featuring Jamie Foxx in what is one of the best hip hop pieces in years. I can't get enough of it. Kanye's musical influences offer some insight into his innovations. He coined the term "white crunk" to describe the "gritty drum sounds of Scottish alternative dance-rock group Franz Ferdinand," whom he apparently claims as one of his favorite bands. It takes good taste to appreciate "white crunk." It was this music that also influenced Diamonds from Sierra Leone, another hit single from Late Registration.
But other tracks, particularly in light of the lyrics, leave much to be desired. He charges in one song that "I know the government administered AIDS" and "they want us all behind bars." In another, he asked "How do we stop the Black Panthers? Ronald Reagan cooked up an answer." Ultimately Kanye follows in a long line of anti-establishment, shock-driven performers. Observe his music in a vacuum and it deserves tremendous acclaim. But his sideshow antics and ridiculous lyrics marginalize what would otherwise be quality work.
Posted by Joshua Claybourn at January 25, 2006 04:52 AM
What a mediocre megalomaniac. So he's saying he's not quite as good as either the Beatles or the Be Sharps, both of whom claimed to be bigger than Jesus?
However catchy or innovative his "music" might be, this guy's ridiculous.
Posted by: Zach Wendling at January 25, 2006 06:55 AM | permalink
A pop star with controversial political views and an over-sized ego? Heaven forefend.
Gold Digger was catchy, but, mostly I liked the Ray Charles' bits.
Posted by: Doug at January 25, 2006 07:02 AM | permalink
I enjoy listening to Kanye's CDs, and think he is pretty creative in comparison to many hip hop artists (or current musicians period). However, I saw him live a few months ago and have to say that it was so bad that I was embarrassed for him. Not only was he utterly unable to sing, rap, dance, or do much else on stage, but his narcissistic presence could only be compared to Scott Stapp's.
I think most of the credit behind Kanye's creative sounds should go to his producers. Beyond that, I tend to agree with Zach's assessment.
Posted by: Jonathan Bunch at January 25, 2006 07:35 AM | permalink
I've never been bothered by the ridiculous political statements of artists. I simply don't care what their political stances are or whether they're reasonable as long as the music is good, the movie entertaining, etc. I think Mel Gibson is a total nutball, but I still enjoy his movies. I thought Rage Against the Machine had some silly faux-revolutionary political ideas, but they were still one of the truly great bands of the last 20 years.
Posted by: Ed Brayton at January 25, 2006 10:35 AM | permalink
I agree with Ed, entertainers should stick to just that...entertaining. There was also an article in the IDS (Indiana Daily Stuent) today about the Oscars/Hollywoods role in politics, pretty good I think: http://www.idsnews.com/news/story.php?adid=search&id=33462
Posted by: Kelli at January 25, 2006 10:48 AM | permalink
Time magazine named him ... "Hip Hop's Class Act".
In the land of the blind, the one-eyed man is king.
Posted by: Eric Seymour at January 25, 2006 03:06 PM | permalink
Borrowing pop-culture icons such as the Mel Gibson necropic to further one's celebrity is hardly shocking. That said, there are few genres in which artists self-aggrandize as much as hip hop, and few artists within that genre who are more prolific in this regard than Kanye West. I'll note that the producer Mr. Bunch compliments is chiefly West himself, although his production style, while noteworthy, is beginning to show signs of fatigue.
Posted by: Chuck at January 25, 2006 04:45 PM | permalink
...and many of the beats and riff that make his production sound so good are recycled from old soul and R&B records. He's never as obvious as Puff Daddy was in the 90s with samples of "Let's Dance" and "Kashmir," but the end result is the same: less songcraft than timing and production, which are, in my opinion, far lesser virtues in the creativity spectrum.
Posted by: Adam Packer at January 25, 2006 06:15 PM | permalink
I first heard of Kanye West when he made the Bush remark. Still never heard his music.
Posted by: Alan K. Henderson at January 26, 2006 12:07 AM | permalink
but his narcissistic presence could only be compared to Scott Stapp's.
Now that's just cruel...
Posted by: andy at January 26, 2006 03:11 AM | permalink
Isn't it funny how celebrities think that the public really cares about their views on political and social issues? I'm still waiting for Alec Baldwin to leave the country because Bush was elected (twice).....
Posted by: lawyerchik1 at January 28, 2006 03:58 PM | permalink
All of you commenting about Kanye must be 40 yrs. old or older. Young people, such as myself, can care less about Kanye's political rampage. When he said that Bush did not care about black people, he was only saying what almost every black person wanted to say. Kanye has the youth rapped up in his fingertips. He wants the same recognition from the grown folks. I understand Kanye completely. When your an music artist, your suppose to walk down the same path everyone else did in the past. However, Kanye is making his own path. He is redefining what pop artists is actually capable of doing. You all need to stop looking at things in black and white. Kanye is practically defying the laws of music artists and I love him to death for that.
Posted by: bigballs at January 28, 2006 10:33 PM | permalink