« Liberalism | Main | Maryland's Anti-Gay Governor »

May 23, 2005

Mascot Madness

I, also, would like to thank the ITA board for extending this opportunity to me. I believe life is a series of opportunities, and your adventures only come when you pick up an opportunity and run with it.

Josh approached me about doing this quite a while back, so I have some posts in the works that might be a little outdated. I still think these issues need to be addressed, however, so old or not, here they come.

Fort Wayne's Indiana Tech became the latest organization to change its sports mascot in the name of sensitivity last week when it removed a Native American warrior symbol for that of a Roman warrior. This is a new twist on this old topic; I cannot recall another situation in which the team or school changed the mascot but not the nickname in the pursuit of the public image of a respectful climate. I suppose a mascot change could be a reasonable compromise when applicable, but isn't a warrior who represents Ft. Wayne's heritage more appropriate? A Native American warrior may have been the most appropriate symbol of the school given its location in Ft. Wayne, which was the site of one of the most triumphant victories of the Native Americans against their pioneer aggressors. Now, however, the school has lost the opportunity to use its mascot as a means for discussion about the heritage of Ft. Wayne and reflection on the struggles of Native Americans in the name of sensitivity. A (quite cowardly-looking) Roman warrior has no value whatsoever.

Marquette University has been struggling mightily with its nickname and mascot for years. Since the 1950s its teams had been known as the Warriors, but in 1994 changed that to the Golden Eagles, and recently announced a change to "Gold." Marquette alumni and students must have had a massive identity crisis at this point, and clearly made their feelings known, because MU has now announced a new naming process after outcry regarding the change to Gold. You can even submit your own suggestion for MU's nickname on the MU website. (NB: votes for "Warriors" will not be counted, and the online suggestions will not be counted as votes). Given the school's Jesuit heritage, I imagine some of the wiseasses around here will have suggestions. Feel free to post your ideas in response; there's nothing better than having some fun at Marquette's expense. Perhaps Pope Benedict XVI will log on and suggest a new nickname in keeping with his well-known feelings about Jesuits. In any case, this story highlights how ridiculous the mascot madness has become.

I will continue to track our nation's universities' drive to be known more for the controversy over their athletic teams' mascots and nicknames than their academic programs.

UPDATE: Marquette has announced the 10 finalists for their "new" nickname, and they include some of the old nicknames that the school has been known for in years past. I am rooting for Golden Eagles to return, which would underscore the silliness at the root of all this.

Posted by Adam Packer at May 23, 2005 09:46 AM

Comments

Chick McGee, a syndicated radio personality, had a clever idea for Miami Univerity (Ohio) when they were struggling with their former mascot, the "Redskins": change the symbol from a Native American to an Apple.

Posted by: Zach Wendling at May 23, 2005 10:53 AM | permalink

There was a school that changed the mascot but not the name, and did so last year. The Merrimack College Warriors (North Andover, MA) changed from an Indian Chief Logo to a Mich. St. Spartan-like warrior mascot and logo last year. Here's a link to the Hockey East website where the new logo can be seen, #6 top row.
http://hockeyeastonline.com/
The old logo can be seen on this clearance t-shirt at
http://www.sportdesigns.com/heashop/mc/mcmwy1.html#

In any event, there's one that kept the name and changed the mascot.

Posted by: Giacomo at May 23, 2005 12:57 PM | permalink

It may just be me, but I seem to notice less outcry when the mascot is the name of a particular tribe, such as FSU Seminoles or U of I Illini, opposed to the generic Warriors, Braves, or Indians. If that observation holds up, Miami might want to try to work out something with the Miami tribe descendants and form an arrangement similar to FSU's. The man seen on horseback at FSU is of Seminole heritage, and the tribe supports the school's use of the name, as long as it is clear that they are honoring the traditions and memory of their ancestors.
Schools like Indiana Tech might want to switch to the name of a tribe who previously inhabited the land. In this case, the Shawnee might work out well.

Posted by: J. P. at May 23, 2005 01:09 PM | permalink

Although I could understand objections over the manner in which certain mascots are portrayed (e.g. Cleveland Indians' Chief Wahoo), I've never understood why having a Native American mascot in general is offensive. Mascots are chosen for their strong, courageous, or inspiring qualities.

Or at least they used to be. Apparently, they're choosing elements now. I'd vote for hydrogen. No matter what happened, you'd always be "number 1."

Posted by: Eric Seymour at May 23, 2005 02:29 PM | permalink

I'm a Miami University alum -- they've already changed their mascot and name to "the Red Hawks". I tend to side with Democrats and liberals in most things these days, but this kind of crap just drives me up a wall.

(Not that conservatives are uniformly better. I went to high school in Richmond Indiana where our mascot was "the Red Devils". Christian groups would periodically make a push to change the mascot to something less Satanic. One of the proposals was "the Rose Buds." -- I happen to think that the psychic damage to a high school football player from playing as a "Rose Bud" would far exceed any problems he has with the occult from playing as a "Red Devil.")

Posted by: Doug at May 23, 2005 02:38 PM | permalink

Good point, Doug. The name-changing business is not all liberals. Chandler Elementary near Evansville changed from Red Devils to Vikings about 20 years ago because of similar concerns, and I am sure there are other examples of this. However, the high-profile mascot changing is usually not of this nature. Sun Devils, Blue Devils, Demon Deacons, etc. all manage to stay unassailed at the national level.

Just because a Native American mascot or symbol is specific or even endorsed by the people it represents doesn't mean it is safe from controversy. The future and welfare of University of Illinois symbol (he's not a mascot) Chief Illiniwek has been THE main issue on campus for years.

Posted by: Adam Packer at May 23, 2005 03:23 PM | permalink

Hey, thanks for the link to the Fort Wayne history. Interesting stuff.

Posted by: Phil at May 23, 2005 11:42 PM | permalink

They should use the 'Trojans', like all the rest of the schools. I'll be glad to design their logo. That shouldn't make the WagonBurners too mad.

Posted by: Rum at May 25, 2005 10:46 AM | permalink

the man on horseback is not of Seminole descent...it's a white student, they paint his face red before the games.

Posted by: Anonymous at June 18, 2005 09:45 PM | permalink

Post a comment




Remember Me?





(you may use HTML tags for style)

 
---- ADVERTISEMENTS ----



Rankings and Aggregators
Technocrati
Blogdom of God
Who Links Here

Site Meter