« Confessions of a GenXer |
Main
| The Strongman Always Rings Twice »
December 31, 2004
God Hates You Just Because
Here's an article from the Washington Post about the reaction of different faith leaders to the tsunami in South Asia. One Christian website writes that the tsunami affected worst those countries that persecute Christians the most; some Indians think the wave was punishment for the arrest of a Hindu religious leader; and one rabbi writes:
This is an expression of God's great ire with the world. The world is being punished for wrongdoing -- be it people's needless hatred of each other, lack of charity, moral turpitude.
I have to say, if these are the best explanations that theology can come up with, maybe we should leave the explanation of geological events to the geologists.
What's galling about these attempts to discern a will behind the tsunami is that the catastrophe wasn't aimed at anyone in particular. What, after all, do the people of Aceh share with Indians or Thais? What did those few people in Somalia who died do to deserve their deaths?
There is nothing new about these questions, of course, but the answers remain unsatisfactory. It is impossible to reconcile the image of a just and loving deity with a deity who murders to send messages. And only the most tortured theological arguments can explain why it is that because of moral turpitude or lack of charity these people should die and these people should live. I wonder, indeed, why some faithful feel the need to explain these acts by recourse to their deity. Who would want to worship such a god? Better to see the divine in the spontaneous compassion of the millions of people worldwide who have been moved to help the victims of the disaster than in the disaster itself.
And the blindness and special pleading of some of these faithful is even more disgusting. If the tsunami is the vengeance of a god on an unholy people, then what does the rabbi think the near-extinction of the American Indians was? Were they being punished for, in effect, their separation from the rest of the human race? We should hope not. To explain those geological and epidemological events through theology would lead to the construction of a theology as nihilistic as that Russell cynically constructed in the first few paragraphs of "A Free Man's Worship."
Update: Dispatches from the Culture Wars wonders if there is an intelligent design theory waiting to be discovered for tsunamis.
Posted by Paul Musgrave at December 31, 2004 09:43 AM
You expect the Washington post to be accurate about believing Christians?
Nope. They will ignore the millions of Christians sending aid to charity, that church groups are sending aid to those countries, and how scholars and saints view such terrible things, and find one semi educated asshole to quote as a "typical" response.
So what else is new?
But if you find someone with an easy answer, you will know that person has never suffered...
But faith reminds us that in the end, God will welcome us to a better world and wipe the tears from our eyes...
Posted by: tioedong at December 31, 2004 10:20 AM | permalink
The idiots get the press, sane believers live quite lives helping others and yes we do try to convert our friends and relatives, but only in respect and gentleness...but thats not good media.
Scripture is clear, it rains on the just and the unjust, bad things happen to good and bad people and it doesn't all get sorted out until we leave this place, any other attempt is a feable mind trying pridefully explain the unexplainable.
Posted by: Mr Bob at December 31, 2004 12:50 PM | permalink
My short answer to the question of God, suffering and natural disasters is that God created the laws of nature, that those laws sometimes have tragic consequences without any specific intent for harm from God, and that despite the fact that miracles do happen, God generally doens't intervene in nature.
My even shorter answer is that God hasn't revealed enough about his nature and creation for us to make much more than a few basic assumptions about God's providence. In other words, I DON'T KNOW WHY.
Posted by: Joel Thomas at December 31, 2004 01:24 PM | permalink
Truthful religions teach that Abraham died, Isaac died, Jacob died, and so did Matthew, Mark, Luke and John; not to forget Buddah and Mohammed. It also teaches that each human death (by cancer or by old age, or by a Tsunami)is God's Judgment!
That Universal Judgment against mankind is that they "must not be allowed to...live forever." (Genesis 3:22) So far no one I know has ever escaped this Divine sentence (not even God's Son)!
True, when the Universal Judgment of Death falls on 100,000 people at once we are more forcefully reminded of our destiny. But when and where death finds us is merely a detail.
God is no more or less Just or Merciful before or after a Tsunami. Those who loose trust because of a catastrophy when God permits what He has willed, could perhaps gain some comfort that God will be equally dilligent in "wiping every tear from their eyes (when) there will be no more death..." and "the sea gives up the dead that were in it."(Revelation 21:4 and 20:13.
Or as St. Paul put it, "For as in Adam all die, so in Christ all will be made alive." (1 Corinthians 15:22) That's God's Universal Judgment too!
Posted by: Jack Hoehn at January 1, 2005 03:58 AM | permalink
Our ancestors gave possession of this planet to Satan. He annoys us as much as possible, but God doesn't let him go over the line.
Posted by: daniel at January 1, 2005 04:55 AM | permalink
I cited this post in my Sunday morning message. Here's the link: http://markdaniels.blogspot.com/2005/01/light-of-world.html.
Thanks to all of you for a terrific blog!
Posted by: Mark at January 3, 2005 12:27 AM | permalink
I agree. You shouldn't expect the WashPost or the NYT or LATimes to be accurate about religion.
Any religion has these idiots, of course, but they are a fringe. And the papers use them to smear the thousands of believers helping in the disaster, from Catholics burying bodies in India to Buddhist monks creamating the dead.
The book of Job tells off those who have easy answers to why men suffer. Perhaps the WaP writer should read it...
Posted by: tioedong at January 3, 2005 08:19 AM | permalink